10:23 Challenge 1984 Aesthetics Alastair Reynolds Alban Berg Albert Uderzo Alexander Nehamas Antikythera Arrugas Art Asterios Polyp Asterix Babylon 5 Bernd and Hilla Becher Bible Bill Viola Brad DeLong Bruce Sterling Buddhism Carl Sagan Center for Inquiry Charles and Ray Eames Charles Burns Charles Yu Cheryl Morgan Chris Mooney Chris Ware Círculo Escéptico Clarkesworld Comics Committee for Skeptical Inquiry Cristóbal Vila Cyberpunk Dan Nadel Darick Robertson Dario Robleto Darryl Cunningham David Mazzucchelli David O'Reilly Dmitri Shostakovich Ed Docx Einstein on the Beach Engaget Eric Brown Errol Morris Etérea Studios Fantasy Fractals Frank Stockton Frankenstein Free Will Gary Wolfe Greece Hans Rosling Harry Frankfurt Hergé Hiraki Sawa Hiroshi Sugimoto Humor Ian Bertram Iliad Jaq Chartier Jason Yungbluth Jennifer Bartlett John Baldessari John Martz John Scalzi John Sculley Jorge Luis Borges Jose Pérez Joseph Lambert Joyce Carol Oates Jules Feiffer Julia Galef Justin Whitaker Karl Stevens Kasimir Malevich Ken Dahl Komar & Melamid Language Lord of the Rings Luis Alfonso Gámez Macintosh Marcel Duchamp Margaret Atwood Mary Shelley Massimo Pigliucci Math Maurizio Cattelan Michael Benson MoCCA Modern Times Museums Nancy Fulda Nancy Kress Neil Gaiman Neil Tyson NK Jemisin NYRSF Optical Illusion Orson Scott Card Paco Roca Pascal Girard Paul Hornschemeier Paul Kurtz Pepo Pérez Phil Moriarty Philip Glass Philosophy physics Plato Podcast Post-modernism Quay Brothers Rage Comics Ray Bradbury Realism Religion Rene Goscinny Richard Dawkins Richard Feynman Robert Rauschenberg Robert Wilson Roger Ebert Sam Sykes Samuel R. Delany Science Science Fiction Sean Carroll Secular Buddhist Association Shaun Tan Sixty Simbols Skepticism SMBC Star Wars Statistics Steampunk Steve Jobs Steven Pinker subBlue Tara Donovan Tatiana Plakhova The New Yorker Theodore Sturgeon Tim Minchin Timothy Callahan Tintin Tom Gauld Tomas Saraceno Transmetropolitan Ursula K. Le Guin Video Vija Celmins Warren Ellis Watchmen Wikileaks Will Eisner William Gibson Wine Writing X'ed Out XKCD

Entries in Asterios Polyp (1)

Tuesday
Jan042011

Asterios Polyp

Recently I've really been getting into comics and graphic novels. They're interrelated genres that one sees bits of in places like the New Yorker or the editorial page of the NYTimes, but it's quite a different thing to sit down and read a whole one by itself.

I think some fiction readers view comics as either universally lightweight (like the Sunday supplements), or as overwrought kids' stuff. Of course, neither is remotely true, though the genre is different from prose fiction. The distinction between a novel and a comic is sort of like that between a stage play and an opera. There's more room for dialogue, description, just sheer words in a stage play than in an opera. In an opera the music takes over much of the deep emotional and narrative function of language, so enormous stories like Wagner's Ring Cycle can work brilliantly on the opera stage, while they would be unwatchable as plays.

In the same way the drawings of comics allow much more information to be got across much more quickly by eye, so comics are denser and usually therefore shorter than equivalent books. Often as a result comics appear overwrought, since stories tend to develop quicker than they would in prose.

At any rate, my topic today is a graphic novel written by David Mazzucchelli, a guy with a background in comics. (Back in the 80s he illustrated Frank Miller's excellent Batman: Year One). It's certainly one of the best books I've read all year, written in a way that should be approachable to an enormous number of potential readers. I'm talking about Asterios Polyp.

It's not superheroes or SF, that's for sure. It does, however, have elements of fantasy and particularly of Greek myth. It's the story of an arrogant professor of architecture and his failed marriage to a young artist. But it's also a story of redemption, following something like the time-worn hero's journey of self recognition and change.

I say the theme is time-worn, but the treatment is fresh, interesting and lively.

It's also gorgeously drawn. Apparently Mazzucchelli worked ten years on the project, and it shows in the artwork as well as the depth of characterization. Each person is given his or her own visual style, and even his or her own font, to help reveal personalities.

I can't recommend this book highly enough. And thanks to the folks at Midtown Comics who recommended it. I can see why they've had trouble keeping them in stock.